Ehh Jasper? the North won.

I know that emmett and edward weren't around for the civil war, but if they were, what side do you think they would have fought for? I'm not sure if you have answered a question like this so... yeah.

i'd say north for edward but i can't be positive about emmett.

I'd say the North for Edward too, but for Emmett I would say the South. I picture him fighting for the underdog and whatnot.

Edward was in Chicago, so he's definitely a Yankee.

Emmett, on the other hand, is from Tennessee, so he's a Confederate.

As for personalities, it's not really fair to say that this person's good and this person's bad according to who they fought for. There were not nice people in both armies, so I couldn't say. I'm not really sure what you're asking. Location played the biggest role deciding which side you fought for. Robert E. Lee believed in the Union and its ideals, but his loyalty to his state (Virginia) ended up more powerful than his loyalty to America.

Sorry I sort of went off! I'm a huge history geek!